Is the use of exceptions a bad practice in scala?

Question

I\'ve seen many times pieces of scala code using Option (for simple values) or Either[List[Error], T] for handling errors.

this gives place to code like this

Answer 1

The following version uses the fact that the right projection of Either is a monad, and is exactly equivalent to your code:

def createApplicationToken(accessToken: AccessToken) = for {
   info <- retrieveProviderInfo(accessToken).right
   user <- User.findOrCreateFromProviderInfo(info).right
   refr <- user.refreshApplicationToken.right
} yield refr.token

And does a much better job of showing off the advantages of Either.

More generally, the rules are the same as in Java: use exceptions for exceptional situations. You just might find that you change your definition of exceptional a bit when you're working in this style—e.g., invalid user input isn't really exceptional, a timed-out network request isn't really exceptional, etc.

Right-biased Either since Scala 2.12

You can now omit .right, so the following code is equivalent since Scala 2.12:

def createApplicationToken(accessToken: AccessToken) = for {
   info <- retrieveProviderInfo(accessToken)
   user <- User.findOrCreateFromProviderInfo(info)
   refr <- user.refreshApplicationToken
} yield refr.token