C# IEnumerator/yield structure potentially bad?

Question

Background: I\'ve got a bunch of strings that I\'m getting from a database, and I want to return them. Traditionally, it would be something like this:

public Li         


        

Answer 1

It's a balancing act: do you want to force all the data into memory immediately so you can free up the connection, or do you want to benefit from streaming the data, at the cost of tying up the connection for all that time?

The way I look at it, that decision should potentially be up to the caller, who knows more about what they want to do. If you write the code using an iterator block, the caller can very easily turned that streaming form into a fully-buffered form:

List stuff = new List(GetStuff(connectionString));

If, on the other hand, you do the buffering yourself, there's no way the caller can go back to a streaming model.

So I'd probably use the streaming model and say explicitly in the documentation what it does, and advise the caller to decide appropriately. You might even want to provide a helper method to basically call the streamed version and convert it into a list.

Of course, if you don't trust your callers to make the appropriate decision, and you have good reason to believe that they'll never really want to stream the data (e.g. it's never going to return much anyway) then go for the list approach. Either way, document it - it could very well affect how the return value is used.

Another option for dealing with large amounts of data is to use batches, of course - that's thinking somewhat away from the original question, but it's a different approach to consider in the situation where streaming would normally be attractive.