Write-Only pointer type

Question

I\'m writing software for an embedded system.

We are using pointers to access registers of an FPGA device.
Some of the registers are read-only, while others are wr

Answer 1

I've worked with a lot of hardware, and some of which has "read only" or "write only" registers (or different functions depending on whether you read or write to the register, which makes for fun when someone decides to do "reg |= 4;" instead of remembering the value it should have, set bit 2 and write the new value, like you should. Nothing like trying to debug hardware that has random bits appearing and disappearing from registers you can't read! ;) I have so far not seen any attempts of actually blocking reads from a write-only register, or writes to read-only registers.

By the way, did I say that having registers that are "write only" is a REALLY bad idea, because you can't read back to check if the software has set the register correctly, which makes debugging really hard - and people writing drivers don't like debugging hard problems that could be made really easy by two lines of VHDL or Verilog code.

If you have some control over the register layout, I would suggest that you put "readonly" registers at a 4KB-aligned address, and "writeonly" registers in another 4KB-aligned address [more than 4KB is fine]. Then you can program the memory controller of the hardware to prevent the access.

Or, let the hardware produce an interrupt if registers that aren't supposed to be read are being read, or registers that aren't supposed to be written are written. I presume the hardware does produce interrupts for other purposes?

The other suggestions made using various C++ solutions are fine, but it doesn't really stop someone who is intent on using the registers directly, so if it's really a safety concern (rather than "let's make it awkward"), then you should have hardware to protect against the misuse of the hardware.