What is a reliable method to record votes from anonymous users, without allowing duplicates

Question

First of all, I searched as best I could and read all SO questions that seem relevant, but nothing specifically answered this. This is not a duplicate, afaik.

Obviously

Answer 1

Anything based on IP addresses isn't an option - the case of NAT has been mentioned, but this seems to only be in the case of home users. There are many larger installations that use NAT - some corporations can have thousands of users pooled behind a single IP address. There are also ISP's that use proxy servers for their users - another case where you can have many thousands of users appear to your application as a single address. Adding unique UA combinations to this won't help, as there isn't enough variation.

A persistent cookie is going to be your best bet - and you'll have to live with the fact that it is easy to game. At least when the cookie is persistent (as opposed to session based) you'll catch the majority of users who run a single browser.

If you really want to rely on the results, you are going to have to add some form of identification in the process (like e-mail validation, which is still gameable).

At the end of the day any internet survey is going to have flaws (like: http://www.time.com/time/arts/article/0,8599,1894028,00.html), and you'll have to live with this.