.NET JIT potential error?

Question

The following code gives different output when running the release inside Visual Studio, and running the release outside Visual Studio. I\'m using Visual Studio 2008 and targeti

Answer 1

I believe this is in a genuine JIT compilation bug. I would report it to Microsoft and see what they say. Interestingly, I found that the x64 JIT does not have the same problem.

Here is my reading of the x86 JIT.

// save context
00000000  push        ebp  
00000001  mov         ebp,esp 
00000003  push        edi  
00000004  push        esi  
00000005  push        ebx  

// put oDoesSomething pointer in ebx
00000006  mov         ebx,ecx 

// zero out edi, this will store oVec.y
00000008  xor         edi,edi 

// zero out esi, this will store oVec.x
0000000a  xor         esi,esi 

// NOTE: the inner loop is unrolled here.
// set oVec.y to 2
0000000c  mov         edi,2 

// call oDoesSomething.Do(oVec) -- y is always 2!?!
00000011  push        edi  
00000012  push        esi  
00000013  mov         ecx,ebx 
00000015  call        dword ptr ds:[002F0010h] 

// call oDoesSomething.Do(oVec) -- y is always 2?!?!
0000001b  push        edi  
0000001c  push        esi  
0000001d  mov         ecx,ebx 
0000001f  call        dword ptr ds:[002F0010h] 

// increment oVec.x
00000025  inc         esi  

// loop back to 0000000C if oVec.x < 2
00000026  cmp         esi,2 
00000029  jl          0000000C 

// restore context and return
0000002b  pop         ebx  
0000002c  pop         esi  
0000002d  pop         edi  
0000002e  pop         ebp  
0000002f  ret     

This looks like an optimization gone bad to me...