Angular JS inject new instance of class

Question

I want to inject instances of a class. From this thread it looks like services return new serviceArgFunction, which is what I want. https://groups.google.com/forum/#!msg/angul

Answer 1

Maximilian - thank you for the great example.

I converted this to JSFiddle, as a place to experiment with another design pattern that I wanted to dig into. Why is it that swapping the provider type from "service" to "factory" still seems to work? It seems more about how the provider is created i.e. using 'new' versus just referencing it directly.

Also, within the service, is there a design pattern as to why a service should implement the "this" keyword, as opposed to using using return { myAccessor : function () { return val; } }

See http://jsfiddle.net/jeffsteinmetz/XF69p/

In this jsfiddle, you can change one line of the code (line 23), and it still works, the line of code can be either:

App.service('MyService', function() {

or

App.factory('MyService', function() {    

Why do these both work?

It seems more about how you reference the service with "new"

  var myInstance = new MyFactory();

Which is different than just calling it directly

  MyService.getVal()

Any angular folks care to lay out the best practices and reasoning behind this:

• when to use 'new' and when you don't need new
• why use the 'this' reference approach to define your provider instead of return { accessorName : function}
• why do both factory or service work in the above example?