Groovy: meaning of 'this' inside a closure

Question

The following example is adapted from \'Groovy in Action\'

class Mother {

    Closure birth() {                            
        def closure = { caller ->         


        

Answer 1

"this" in a block mean in Groovy always (be it a normal Java-like block or a Closure) the surrounding class (instance). "owner" is a property of the Closure and points to the embedding object, which is either a class (instance), and then then same as "this", or another Closure. I would forget about the scope thing totally for this part. So in the case above it is correct, that "this" refers to a mother.

And now to make things complicated... "this" and the implicit this are not the same in Groovy. So if you have a Closure {foo()} and {this.foo()} you can get differing results. this.foo() will always be resolved to the embedding class, while only foo() will be resolved using the Groovy meta object protocol (MOP) and can point to something entirely different. A builder may for example set a delegate on that Closure and catch the method invocation, for a Groovy builder that is standard. Anyway... that is why this part is called dynamic scoping.

Historic background: Before Groovy 1.0 "this" was the Closure object itself. But was changed because actually calling this.foo() became impossible if a builder did capture all calls. then you had no way to call local methods from within the builder anymore. There was a lot of tries with changing the standard resolve strategy - and big emotional discussions too. But in the end, changing "this" to refer to the embedding class was a simple solution to the problem and is more in line with people coming from Java plus it let's you easily bypass the MOP if you insist.