Is this is an ExpressionTrees bug? #2

Question

Looks like ExpressionTrees compiler should be near with the C# spec in many behaviors, but unlike C# there is no support for conversion from decimal to any en

Answer 1

It is probably a bug, and it is probably my fault. Sorry about that.

Getting decimal conversions right was one of the hardest parts of building the expression tree code correct in the compiler and the runtime because decimal conversions are actually implemented as user-defined conversions in the runtime, but treated as built-in conversions by the compiler. Decimal is the only type with this property, and therefore there are all kinds of special-purpose gear in the analyzer for these cases. In fact, there is a method called IsEnumToDecimalConversion in the analyzer to handle the special case of nullable enum to nullable decimal conversion; quite a complex special case.

Odds are good that I failed to consider some case going the other way, and generated bad code as a result. Thanks for the note; I'll send this off to the test team, and we'll see if we can get a repro going. Odds are good that if this does turn out to be a bona fide bug, this will not be fixed for C# 4 initial release; at this point we are taking only "user is electrocuted by the compiler" bugs so that the release is stable.