I get the following error in Visual Studio 2008:
Error 1 A local variable named \'i\' cannot be declared in this scope because it would give a different meaning
I think you're all confusing C++ and C#.
In C++, it used to be that the scope of a variable declared in a for expression was external to the block that followed it. This was changed, some time ago, so that the scope of a variable declared in a for expression was internal to the block that followed it. C# follows this later approach. But neither has anything to do with this.
What's going on here is that C# doesn't allow one scope to hide a variable with the same name in an outer scope.
So, in C++, this used to be illegal. Now it's legal.
for (int i; ; )
{
}
for (int i; ; )
{
}
And the same thing is legal in C#. There are three scopes, the outer in which 'i' is not defined, and two child scopes each of which declares its own 'i'.
But what you are doing is this:
int i;
for (int i; ; )
{
}
Here, there are two scopes. An outer which declares an 'i', and an inner which also declares an 'i'. This is legal in C++ - the outer 'i' is hidden - but it's illegal in C#, regardless of whether the inner scope is a for loop, a while loop, or whatever.
Try this:
int i;
while (true)
{
int i;
}
It's the same problem. C# does not allow variables with the same name in nested scopes.