webservices with repository pattern in c# and WCF?

Question

Can anyone confirm the best way to integrate the repository pattern with webservices.... Well actually i have my repository patter working now in c#. I have 3 projects, DataAcce

Answer 1

Whether to share your Service/API assemblies with your client applications is fairly subjective. If you are a full Microsoft shop, and use .NET for your entire application stack, then I would say sharing the API is a great way to gain code reuse (you have to be careful how you design your API so you don't bleed domain concerns, like repositories, into your presentation.) If you don't have any plans to migrate your client applications to other platforms (i.e. you plan to stay on .NET for the foreseeable future), then I think its perfectly acceptable to share your Service/API assemblies (and even then, in a multi-platform client environment, sharing Service/API with .NET clients should still be acceptable.) There is always a trade off between the 'architecturally ideal' and the 'practical and achievable within budget'. You can spend a LOT of time, money, and effort trying to achieve the architecturally ideal, when the gap between that and the practical often isn't really that much. The choice NOT to share the API and essentially recreate it to maintain "correct" SOA, consuming only the contract, can actually increase work and introduce maintenance hassles that quite possibly are not worth it for your particular project at this particular time. Given that you are already generally 'service-oriented', if at a future point in time you need the benefit that contract-only consumption on the client can offer, then your already set to go there. But don't push too far too soon.

Given your needs, from what I have been able to glean from these posts so far, I think your on the right track from your services down too. A repository (a la Evans, DDD) is definitely a domain concern, and as such, you really shouldn't have to worry about it from the perspective of your presentation layer. You services are the gateway to your domain, which is the home of your business logic. Repositories are just a support facility that helps you achieve domain isolation from a data store (they are glorified collections really, and to be quite frank...they can be a bit of a pain in a dynamic and complex domain. Simple data mappers, (Fowler, PofEAA) are often a lot easier to deal with and less complex in the long run, and allow more adaptable behavior around your data retrieval logic to be centralized in your domain services.) Aside from heavy use of AJAX calls to REST Services, if you expose adequate Services/API around your domain, that is the only thing that your clients should have worry about. Wrap up all the rest of your business logic entirely within the confines of your domain, and keep your clients as light weight as possible and abstracted from concepts like 'Repository' or 'Data Mapper' and whatnot.

In my experience, the only non-service or API concept that needs to be shared across the Client-to-Domain boundary is Context...and it can be notoriously difficult to cross that boundary in a service-oriented application.