Efficient user interfaces

Question

Speed and learnability do not directly fight each other, but it seems easy enough to design such a GUI that lacks either (or both) of them. GUI designers seem to prefer \'easy t

Answer 1

Rant (or, Stuff I think you should keep in mind):

Speed and learnability do directly fight each other. A menu item tells you what it does so that you don't have to remember. But it's much slower than a keyboard shortcut that you have to memorize to benefit from. The general technique for resolving this conflict seems to be allowing more than one way of doing things. While one way of doing something usually cannot be both fast and easy to learn, you can often provide two ways to accomplish the same task: one that's fast, and one that's obvious.

There are different kinds of people. The learning gap is a result of interest, motivation, intellectual capacity, etc. There is a class of person that will never bother to even learn which menu provides the action they want, and they'll scrub the menubar every time. There is also a (minority) class of person that thinks vim (or emacs) is the best thing since sliced bread. Most people probably fall somewhere in between these extremes.

My answer to the actual question:

I think you are asking how to strive for a fast UI. Your question wasn't particularly clear (to me).

• First of all, be consistent. This helps both speed and learnability. Self consistency is the most important, but consistency with your environment may also be important.

• For real speed, require as little attention and motion as possible. Keyboard shortcuts are fast because experienced users know where they are (they don't have to look), and their hands are already on the keyboard. Especially avoid forcing the user to change their position in front of the computer (e.g., moving one hand between the mouse and keyboard).

• The keyboard is almost always faster than the mouse.

• Customization (especially the ability to write custom scripts) will let power users make the interface work the way that is fastest for their specific habits.

• Make it possible to get by without the most powerful features. All you need to know in order to survive in vim is "i, ESC, :wq, :q!". With that, you can use vi about the same way a lot of people use notepad. but once you start learning "h,j,k,l,w,b,e,d,c" (and so on) you get much more efficient. So there is a steep learning curve, but you can get by until you surmount it.

• Keep in mind that if you focus on interface efficiency, you will probably limit your user base. Vim is popular among programmers, but lots of programmers use other tools, and it's virtually unknown among non-programmers. Most people want easy, not fast. Some want a balance. A very few just want fast.