How can I embed an unmanaged C++ form into a .NET application?

Question

I have been able to successfully wrap my unmanaged Borland C++ dll, and launch it\'s forms from a C# .NET 4.0 application. Is it possible to embed a form from the dll directly i

Answer 1

Note I wrote this response assuming that the OP wanted to literally embed the native DLL containing the form in the .NET app, not just modify the way in which it's displayed.

In short, no. You'll need to package the C++ DLL with your distribution and import/wrap its functions the same way that you're doing now.

I seem to recall from my Delphi (which uses the same compiler back-end as Borland C++) days that the form designer generates C++ code which creates a winproc/message loop, etc for each of the assets in the form via with Win32 API.

Since all of that code is unmanaged, it can't be compiled into a managed assembly. You could port it to managed C++, but that would kill most of the benefit of having it in C++ to start with, and you're stuck with a crappy exception model and all of the other wonderful parts of C++. In that case, you'd probably be better off just rewriting it in C#.

But, since this is software, and almost anything is possible, here's a really lame solution: embed the DLL as a binary resource in your .NET app and, at run time, pull its contents into a binary stream, save it to disk and then load it (I'm not sure if there is a way to execute an unmanaged DLL from memory, other than cheating by putting it on a RAM disk).

The only thing this gets you is the ability to hide the DLL, but I really don't see the point.

Edit Do you mean embed as in show as a child window, or embed as in place the code within the .NET project?