CPU and GPU differences

Question

What is the difference between a single processing unit of CPU and single processing unit of GPU?
Most places I\'ve come along on the internet cover the high level differen

Answer 1

Short answer

The main difference between GPUs and CPUs is that GPUs are designed to execute the same operation in parallel on many independent data elements, while CPUs are designed to execute a single stream of instructions as quickly as possible.

Detailed answer

Part of the question asks

In the CPU, the FPU runs real number operations. How fast are the same operations being done in each GPU core? If fast then why is it fast?

This refers to the floating point (FP) execution units that are used in CPUs and GPUs. The main difference is not how a single FP execution unit is implemented. Rather the difference is that a CPU core will only have a few FP execution units that operate on independent instructions, while a GPU will have hundreds of them that operate on independent data in parallel.

GPUs were originally developed to perform computations for graphics applications, and in these applications the same operation is performed repeatedly on millions of different data points (imagine applying an operation that looks at each pixel on your screen). By using SIMD or SIMT operations the GPU reduces the overhead of processing a single instruction, at the cost of requiring multiple instructions to operate in lock-step.

Later GPGPU programming became popular because there are many types of programming problems besides graphics that are suited to this model. The main characteristic is that the problem is data parallel, namely the same operations can be performed independently on many separate data elements.

In contrast to GPUs, CPUs are optimized to execute a single stream of instructions as quickly as possible. CPUs use pipelining, caching, branch prediction, out-of-order execution, etc. to achieve this goal. Most of the transistors and energy spent executing a single floating point instruction is spent in the overhead of managing that instructions flow through the pipeline, rather than in the FP execution unit. While a GPU and CPU's FP unit will likely differ somewhat, this is not the main difference between the two architectures. The main difference is in how the instruction stream is handled. CPUs also tend to have cache coherent memory between separate cores, while GPUs do not.

There are of course many variations in how specific CPUs and GPUs are implemented. But the high-level programming difference is that GPUs are optimized for data-parallel workloads, while CPUs cores are optimized for executing a single stream of instructions as quickly as possible.