Is it possible to subclass a C struct in C++ and use pointers to the struct in C code?

Question

Is there a side effect in doing this:

C code:

struct foo {
      int k;
};

int ret_foo(const struct foo* f){ 
    return f.k; 
}

C++ c

Answer 1

I don't think it is necessarily a problem. The behaviour is well defined, and as long as you are careful with life-time issues (don't mix and match allocations between the C++ and C code) will do what you want. It should be perfectly portable across compilers.

The problem with destructors is real, but applies any time the base class destructor isn't virtual not just for C structs. It is something you need to be aware of but doesn't preclude using this pattern.