I have several of these in my code which have been working fine so far:
#If DEBUG Then
... some code here
#End If
Now, i am
Firstly, make sure you understand the difference between how you're running the code and how you're building it. Too many people equate "launching in a debugger" with "the debug version" and "launching not in a debugger" with "the release version". They're completely orthogonal - you can launch a release build in a debugger (typically with less information available) and you can launch a debug build not in a debugger. Apologies if you were already aware of this.
Now, assuming you really have changed the project configuration you're building to Release, you need to check the project properties for that specific configuration. I don't know what it looks like in VB, but in C# in the project properties, in the build tab, there will be a list of defined symbols - that is what affects whether #if DEBUG
code is built or not. Perhaps someone has copied over the project configuration from Debug into Release?
EDIT: One way to check this at build time is:
#if DEBUG
#error This shouldn't happen
#endif
In a release build, that should build without error. In debug, it won't.
EDIT: Another option is that your overall solution configuration is now referring to the wrong project configuration types. I can't remember the exact menu name, but if you look around Project for Configuration Manager, you should be able to bring up a grid mapping "Project" and "Solution Configuration" to the project configuration to build.