How bad is “if (!this)” in a C++ member function?

Question

If I come across old code that does if (!this) return; in an app, how severe a risk is this? Is it a dangerous ticking time bomb that requires an immediate app-wide

Answer 1

You can safely fix this today by returning a failed lookup object.

class CLookupThingy: public Interface {
  // ...
}

class CFailedLookupThingy: public Interface {
 public:
  CThingy* Lookup(string const& name) {
    return NULL;
  }
  operator bool() const { return false; }  // So that GetLookup() can be tested in a condition.
} failed_lookup;

Interface *GetLookup() {
  if (notReady())
    return &failed_lookup;
  // else etc...
}

This code still works:

CThingy *pFoo = GetLookup()->Lookup( "foo" ); // will set pFoo to NULL without crashing